Check a VIN

Buick Regal won't shift problems

12 of the 2,973 owner complaints about the Buick Regal describe stuck in gear or won't shift, most of them for the 2011 model year.

owner complaints
12
worst model year
2011
typical mileage
83,000
Is there a fix? There are 2 recalls for this area of the car. See below

By model year

  • 2016
    2
  • 2013
    1
  • 2011
    5
  • 2004
    1
  • 2001
    1
  • 2000
    1
  • 1995
    1

What owners say

Filed Mar 13, 2025 · Electrical, Engine · MI

I have a continuous problem where the vehicle goes into limp mode/reduce power mode it studders and stalls out. The check engine and stabilitrak light comes on. It is extreamly dangerous at it happens on the road and in traffic. I have thousands of dollars, a new thortle body sensor, a new crank positioner, new timing chain, new ECM, new gaskets and so much more.

Filed Aug 9, 2019 · Engine · 83,000 miles · NY

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 buick regal. While driving approximately 25 MPH, the check engine warning indicator illuminated intermittently, which caused the vehicle to go into limp mode. The contact mentioned that the vehicle failed to accelerate more than 1 MPH. In addition, the vehicle needed to be restarted in order to operate. The contact called vision buick gmc (800 panorama trail s, rochester, ny 14625, (585) 200-3905) and informed them of the failure. The vehicle was not diagnosed or repaired. The manufacturer was not notified of the failure. The approximate failure mileage was 83,000.

Filed Jul 8, 2019 · Electrical, Engine · 60,000 miles · VA

2011 buick regal purchased from show room floor in 2011. Presentative maintenance up to date. No warning lights. Something terribly wrong with transmission, engine. While driving on city street approaching interstate at 25 MPH, car starting stalling, puttering, losing power. Pulled over, put in park. Then car would not go into gear. Would accelerate but would not go into gear or move. Had to be towed. First thing dealer service center suggest is $3000 transmission. Car only has 60,000 miles, one owner. No way! No prior symptoms or warning lights, in fact onstar diagnostics currently showing no issues found with engine/transmission system. This car is unsafe and should be recalled!!! 2011 buick regal diagnostics report from your 2011 buick regal as of 07/08/2019 no issues found

Filed Mar 1, 2019 · Engine, Steering · 93,000 miles · ID

Our cur completely shut off all power lights engine everything doing 80 MPH on interstate 84 in idaho. A semi seen it happen jumped in the middle of both lanes to block traffic so we could get to the shoulder. In a no cell phone area 13 we disconnected the battery and had to shift srive it in limp mode. No alert lights came on we took it yo a certified dealer to find the pistons, timing chain and other things are ntoken gm/ buick was notified they decided to decline assistance because we are out of warranty 93k miles on the car and over 5,000$ in repair and possibly another 2100$ to repair the cadilitic converter. We were in a no cell service area and had to drive in the shoulder now the headlights won't turn on at all either. The car never alert us it just shut off the dealer says the oil was very low again no oil light came on with that yhe dealer says therecould be a bcm/ECM communication issue costing 1200.00 to 2500.00 to fix. They can't assess completely until the piston/ timing belt issue is fixed but the car is not communicating the steering is now super tight and the only yhing it says now is service stibilatrac and the mechanic didn't even bring that up

Filed Dec 17, 2018 · Driver assistance, Transmission · 35,000 miles · CA

I was driving down the highway in texas, and was in the process of changing lanes to the left and accelerating when all of a sudden my vehicle completely lost power and would not go into gear. My transmission light immediately came on. The psl was 70 and thankfully I was able to move back into the right lane and navigate to the shoulder without getting hit. I eventually coasted off the hwy and had aaa tow my car to the dealership where it was determined my transmission needing rebuilding. This occurred around 30k miles. Periodically after that my car would not accelerate like I had a misfire and I'd feel a shudder or sometimes it felt my tires were spinning faster than my transmission was going. I took my car in for an oil change (no lights were on). I explained this to the dealership and my car was throwing a code turns out the torque converter needing replacing. This was under 50k miles. I am currently at 52k miles and when I go up a high I feel the same thing and have told the dealership this. They won't give me a loaner car and I can't be without my car so I have not currently brought it back in. There are no lights on but it feels like the same issue is starting back when the torque converter went out. I have always had my car serviced at the dealership so I have all the records.

Filed Sep 12, 2018 · Transmission · 47,500 miles · FL

Vehicle had 45000 mile's when I bought it in oct 2017 and now has 47500 miles. Car had no problems and drove and looks like new. Last week (09/07/18) it started bucking going down road at @30mph, then would jump into gears at stop. Then did not want to go into reverse. Would not shift out in forward gears. Manual would not work either. We were stuck in traffic at busy intersection...all in about 10 minutes time. Limped to aamco transmissions and left it...diagnosis was needed to rebuild transmission..cost;3400.00 have read this has happened on other 2011 models. Should have been a recall..45000 miles is still like new and this should have and could have been avoided..I was lucky to have not been in an accident. Was just driving normal in city when happened.

Filed Jul 13, 2017 · Transmission · 120,000 miles · MI

While merging onto a busy highway, the transmission would not shift into 3rd gear. It lost power and almost caused an accident. There was no previous warning of a transmission problem. The traffic was heavy because of the holiday weekend. With little room to merge, I attempted to speed up with traffic when it failed. I was forced to pull over and limp along the side of the road in second gear until the next exit with cars flying by at 70-80 MPH. This was caused by the "wave plate" in the transmission coming apart according to the transmission shop. They also said this is a very common problem with these transmissions. Buick knows about this problem as listed in 2007-2009 recalls but does not do anything for 2011 models. There is also a pia bulletin pi0780a for this exact same problem and model year. Gm refused to take responsibility for it. There are several forums with the same problem. It it going to get someone killed.

Filed Jun 7, 2017 · Fuel system, Suspension · 18,000 miles · CA

Car computer is suceptible to hacking and reprogramming while driving suspension is lowered or raised engine looses power whole car components rattle or radio bass loud while driving transmission doesnt shift to correct gear stuck on second or third and gear shift knob pops up while driving dealer says is normal brakes loose pressure taking long to complete stop engine shakes while in motion or idle radio and other components apps traction ABS disabled hacked or controlled wireless/bt

Filed May 16, 2014 · Driver assistance, Electrical · 84,000 miles · TN

I was driving the car at 40mph when all of a sudden it cut off and all the gauge lights came on. I was nearly side swiped by another car. I restarted the car but it would not start. I tried to start it up again. It started but would not shift out of park. The gauge lights on the dash board were still on. I restarted the car again and was able to drive it home; the signal lights and head lights did not work. When I was finally able to start it up and take it to a mechanic, I was told the problem was the ignition switch. I paid a total of $540 for them to repair this problem. Gmc knew about the problem and did not report a recall to consumers nor offer to fix it. All I'm asking is for a refund of the money I paid; $540.

Filed May 6, 2012 · Driver assistance, Electrical · 150,000 miles · GA

2000 buick regal ls, when start car up, then drive the car for about 10-15 minutes and all the lights start flickering, and the car shut down, and I tries to start it back up, it cuts right back off I let it cool down for about an hour or 2 and it start right back up but the gear will not go out of park will not shift.

Related recalls

Power train: automatic transmissionReported February 21, 2014 · 355 vehicles affected
What is wrong
General Motors LLC (GM) is recalling certain model year 2014 Buick Regal, LaCrosse, Verano, and Enclave, and Chevrolet Impala, Malibu, Cruze, and Traverse, and GMC Acadia vehicles equipped with automatic transmissions. In the affected vehicles, the transmission shift cable adjuster may disengage from the transmission shift lever. As such, these vehicles do not conform to Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) number 102, "Transmission Shift Lever Sequence, Starter Interlock, and Transmission Braking Effect." They also fail to conform to FMVSS number 114, "Theft Protection and Rollaway Prevention."
Risk
If a vehicle's shift cable disengages from the transmission shift lever, a driver may be unable to shift gear positions and the indicated shift position may not represent the gear position the vehicle is in. Should a disengagement occur while the vehicle is being driven, when the driver goes to stop and park the vehicle, the driver may be able to shift the lever to the "PARK" position, but the vehicle transmission may not be in the "PARK" gear position. If the vehicle is not in the "PARK" position there is a risk the vehicle will roll away as the driver and other occupants exit the vehicle or anytime thereafter. A vehicle rollaway increases the risk of injury to exiting occupants and bystanders.
Remedy
General Motors will notify owners, and dealers will inspect and replace any affected transmission shift cable adjusters, free of charge. The recall began on April 10, 2014. Chevrolet owners may contact General Motors at 1‑800‑222‑1020, Buick owners at 1‑800‑521‑7300, and GMC owners at 1‑800‑462‑8782. General Motors' number associated with this recall is 14048.

Recall number 14V092000 · Recall details

Power train: automatic transmissionReported December 6, 1991 · 10,141 vehicles affected
What is wrong
The reverse servo apply pin may bind in the case which could cause reverse band distress (loss or slipping of reverse), reverse band drag in drive range (poor performance -- poor power), or the transmission to remain in reverse while the shift indicator shows neutral gear position.
Risk
If the transmission remains in reverse while the shiftindicator shows neutral, the vehicle may unexpectedly move rearward and resultin a vehicle accident.
Remedy
Replace the transaxle where required.

Recall number 91V214000 · Recall details

Questions about the Buick Regal won't shift

Which Buick Regal years have stuck in gear or won't shift problems?

The model years with the most reports are 2011 (5 complaints), 2016 (2 complaints) and 1995 (1 complaints).

VIN decoder

See the problems and recalls for an exact car

Buying a used Buick Regal?

Check the exact car before you pay: accidents, salvage or flood titles, odometer readings and previous owners.

Check its history